By Dr. Joel Ramsey, The Paranormal Professor
They had planned to see their son later that year.
He died before that visit could take place. Several conversations they had been meaning to have with him never happened either. There were things they had intended to say, things they assumed there would still be time to discuss. After he was gone, those unspoken words did not simply disappear. They stayed.
What brought his parents to me was not grief, exactly. They did not come looking for a therapist or a grief counselor, and I am neither. What brought them to me was something they had been experiencing in their home, a sense that their son was still present, that something in the house had not moved on even though he had. They wanted someone to take that seriously without telling them what it meant.
That is what I try to do.
A Framework for Grief That Does Not Resolve
In the 1970s, family therapist Pauline Boss developed a concept she called ambiguous loss. Her framework describes situations in which the status of a relationship, or the nature of a loss itself, remains unclear. The classic examples are someone who has disappeared without explanation, still present in the minds of those who loved them but absent from their lives, and someone who remains physically present but has become psychologically unreachable, as can happen with severe dementia or other conditions that alter the self.
What Boss identified was that this kind of uncertainty, the not-knowing whether someone is truly gone or still somehow there, creates a particular kind of grief that ordinary mourning rituals are poorly designed to address (Boss, 1999). Our cultural scripts for bereavement assume that loss has a beginning and an end. Ambiguous loss disrupts that assumption at its foundation.
The parents who came to me had not experienced an ambiguous loss in Boss’s specific sense. Their son’s death was confirmed. There was no uncertainty about whether he was gone. But their grief carried a different kind of unresolved weight, one that the research on unfinished business in bereavement describes more directly.
Klingspon and colleagues (2015) examined what they called unfinished business in bereaved individuals: the sense that something important was left incomplete at the time of a death, a conversation that did not happen, an opportunity to repair or deepen a relationship that the death made impossible. Their research found that this sense of incompleteness was associated with more prolonged and complicated grief responses. The loss itself may be certain. What remains uncertain is the meaning of what was left unsaid, and what, if anything, can be done with that now.
From a communication perspective, there is another dimension to this kind of loss. Relationships are sustained through conversations, shared meanings, and expectations about what we will say to one another in the future. When someone dies unexpectedly, those anticipated conversations disappear. The words remain with the living, but the person they were intended for is no longer available to receive them. For the parents I met, that interruption was part of what made their loss so difficult to comprehend.
This is the challenge that unresolved grief and continuing attachment can present to paranormal investigation. Although the loss itself is not ambiguous, the emotional meaning of what remains unfinished may be profoundly uncertain.
What the Parents Told Me
My approach to cases like this one begins with listening. This is the foundation of what I call the Ramsey Communication-Based Investigation Protocol, the conviction that an investigator’s first responsibility is to understand what a person is actually experiencing before moving toward any interpretation of it.
The parents described experiences that convinced them their son was still present. They spoke about seeing him and sensing his presence, experiences that carried enormous emotional significance in the aftermath of his death. They were not asking me to confirm that their son was haunting their house. They were asking me to investigate without dismissing what they had experienced, and to be honest with them about what I found.
Their accounts raised questions that the research on unfinished business and continuing bonds could help illuminate. The unresolved conversations, the anticipated visit that would never take place, and the powerful sense of connection to their son all provided important context. None of those circumstances, however, established the cause of the experiences they reported.
When the Bereaved Experience the Deceased
Before reaching for paranormal explanations, or ruling them out, it is worth recognizing how commonly bereaved individuals report experiences of the deceased that feel deeply real.
A 2020 interdisciplinary review published in Schizophrenia Bulletin examined what researchers call sensory and quasi-sensory experiences of the deceased in bereavement. Kamp and colleagues, whose team included researchers Edith Steffen and Jacqueline Hayes, reviewed the existing literature on these experiences, which can include sensing the presence of a deceased person, hearing their voice, seeing them, or feeling touched by them (Kamp et al., 2020).
Crucially, the review found that such experiences are common among the bereaved, that they occur across cultures, and that they do not, by themselves, indicate psychiatric illness. For many people who experience them, they are meaningful, even comforting. These experiences are not necessarily associated with unresolved grief or unfinished business; they may also occur among bereaved individuals whose relationships with the deceased were loving, secure, and relatively free of unresolved conflict.
This matters for paranormal investigation in a specific way. When someone reports an experience that resembles what researchers call a post-bereavement hallucinatory experience, that experience deserves to be taken seriously on its own terms. The research documenting these phenomena does not establish whether the deceased are actually present. It examines the experiences and their meanings. That distinction is central to this work.
The parents I spoke with had not read this research. They simply knew what they had experienced in their home. Part of my responsibility was to understand that context clearly before conducting any investigation.
What Attachment Theory Adds
One of the more important contributions of modern grief psychology is its recognition that the bonds between people do not simply end at death.
Psychologist John Bowlby’s work on attachment described the profound distress that follows the disruption of a close bond, and the internal processes by which a person adjusts to loss over time (Bowlby, 1980). What his framework suggested, and what later grief researchers expanded upon, is that the internal representation of a person we love does not simply dissolve when they die. We carry them with us.
Klass, Silverman, and Nickman’s work on continuing bonds challenged the older assumption that healthy grieving required the bereaved to detach from the deceased and redirect their emotional investment elsewhere (Klass et al., 1996). Their research found that many bereaved individuals maintain an ongoing relationship with the person they have lost, through memory, ritual, and sometimes through a sense of continued presence. Maintaining a continuing bond is not inherently pathological. Depending on its nature and circumstances, that bond may provide comfort, contribute to adjustment, or become associated with continuing distress.
What this means for a case like the one these parents brought to me is that a powerful, ongoing sense of connection to their son was not, in itself, surprising. It was consistent with what we know about how grief works. It was also not, by itself, an explanation for what they reported experiencing in their home. Those are two separate questions, and treating them as separate is essential.
What an Investigator Can Offer
I cannot tell grieving parents whether their son is present in their house. That is not a question I can answer, and I would not pretend otherwise.
What I can do is investigate carefully, listen without rushing to a conclusion, and be honest about the difference between what I found, what I cannot explain, and what the psychological context might illuminate. A reported experience may occur within the context of profound grief while its underlying cause remains uncertain. Recognizing the psychological circumstances surrounding an experience does not, by itself, establish what produced it. Nor does the absence of an immediate explanation establish a paranormal cause.
Paranormal investigation at its best does not compete with grief. It does not replace bereavement counseling, and it does not offer a shortcut past the hard work of mourning. What it can offer, in certain cases, is a willingness to examine experiences that people may find difficult to discuss openly, without prematurely dismissing them or claiming certainty about their cause.
Grief research gives investigators like me important tools for understanding the context in which reported experiences occur. It does not give us a script for what those experiences mean. The parents I spoke with were not looking for a script. They were looking for someone who would listen to what they had experienced and treat it, and them, with respect.
Sometimes the most important thing an investigator can offer is not an answer. It is the willingness to sit with the question alongside the people who are living inside it.
Listen first. Investigate what remains.
References
Boss, P. (1999). Ambiguous loss: Learning to live with unresolved grief. Harvard University Press.
Bowlby, J. (1980). Attachment and loss: Vol. 3. Loss: Sadness and depression. Basic Books.
Kamp, K. S., Steffen, E. M., Alderson-Day, B., Allen, P., Austad, A., Hayes, J., Larøi, F., Ratcliffe, M., & Sabucedo, P. (2020). Sensory and quasi-sensory experiences of the deceased in bereavement: An interdisciplinary and integrative review. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 46(6), 1367–1381. https://doi.org/10.1093/schbul/sbaa113
Klass, D., Silverman, P. R., & Nickman, S. L. (Eds.). (1996). Continuing bonds: New understandings of grief. Taylor & Francis.
Klingspon, K. L., Holland, J. M., Neimeyer, R. A., & Lichtenthal, W. G. (2015). Unfinished business in bereavement. Death Studies, 39(7), 387–398. https://doi.org/10.1080/07481187.2015.1029143





Comments